The PopesBacon's Negative Hero | Bacon painted the portrait of Pope Innocent X after Velazquez in 1951, and immediately followed
it up with two [
I II
]
further pictures based on the same image. But the subject-matter was by no
means exhausted with the completion of this three-part series: over the next fourteen years Bacon
returned to the same motif again and again, in a total of forty-five works.
He seemed almost incapable
of tearing himself away from the theme, which occupied him for longer than any other.
In 1965 the
series came to an end whose abruptness suggested an almost violent act of liberation -
a view corroborated by Bacons comments in his interview of May 1966 with David Sylvester.
Only once, 1971, did Bacon use the motif again, but this time, instead of taking Velazquez as his
model, he based the work on one of his own previous pictures: the 1962 Study from Innocent X.
Francis Bacon
Study after Velazquez I, 1950 Bacon never saw the original Velazquez. And although he spent three months in Rome in 1954, he carefully avoided
visiting the Galleria Pamphilij.
He seemed afraid of encountering the original, as if he were insufficiently
prepared for the experience of seeing it with his own eyes, or as if he felt unworthy of the privilege. It is also possible
that he was afraid of being disappointed: perhaps his mental image of the painting was so powerful that he was unwilling to risk
a first hand encounter which might diminish its stature.
Over the years he had acquired a large collection of books, catalogues and postcards with reproductions of the portrait, which he had studied over and over again, to the point where he knew every last detail of it like the back of his hand. In his mind Velazquez's portrait had taken on a life of its own. This life he wishes to preserve. If he were exposed to the painting's reality and saw the details of its technique, the
effect might well be to destroy the inner vision that he had so often cited and varied. As a result, he left Rome without ever setting foot inside the Palazzo Doria.
That Bacon never saw the original of the Velazquez is regrettable for several reasons. A direct confrontation with the work might have incited him to produce further variations, perhaps with different emphasis. But it would have also validated his own work in a specific way by allowing him to appreciate the freedom of Velazquez's painting technique. This cannot be conveyed by reproductions, which tend, for example, to suggest that the reflections of light on the Pope's red cape are exactly calculated and executed with meticulous attention to detail. In fact, however,
Velazquez painted them quite spontaneously, with the confident fluency of a master whose aim is to evoke the appearance of things, rather than to describe them naturalistically.
In this respect, his approach to painting anticipates one of Bacon's central tenets: that the artist should leave sufficient
scope for the intervention of chance, while at the same time striving for the highest possible degree of precision.
From the outset, Bacon combined his personal interpretation of Velazquez's Pope with two further motifs whose fascination never waned and which recur in various combinations throughout his oeuvre. The first of these is the gaping, screaming mouth, the second is the human figure elevated above the
crowd and set on a kind of stage, which renders it especially conspicuous. The first motif refers, on the one hand, to the image of the screaming nurse maid in the Odessa steps sequence of Eisenstein's film 'Battleship Potemkin', and on the other, to the illustrations of diseases of the mouth in a medical textbook that Bacon found in a second hand bookshop in Paris.
The second motif owes its inspiration to a photograph of Pope Pius XII art galleries swaying above the heads of the faithful as he was carried through the Vatican in the processional throne. The emphasis on the individual, in visual rather than hierarchical terms, was the aspect that particularly intrigued Bacon in traditional depictions of the Crucifixion.
These three ideas - the Velazquez portrait of Innocent X, the photograph of Pius XII on his throne, and the image of the screaming nurse in the midst of pre-Revolutionary chaos - merged into a composite whole that remained intact for many years and only began to disintegrate in the later works from the Velazquez series.
The image that paled first was the most recent of the three: the image of Pius XII. Initially this had been the dominant model: in Head VI the first painting to link to the three motifs, its central importance is obvious.
This work does not properly belong to the series of Pope pictures; its significance is that of a precursor or a point of departure, and although the image of Innocent X
governs in the background, it has not yet become the main force shaping the picture as a whole.
A further two years elapsed before the Velazquez motif asserted full control over the picture. However, the 1949 Head already anticipates the spatial device that was to become such a characteristic feature of Bacon's work: the figure is enclosed in a transparent cage, a structure of fine lines that marks out a space within a space.
Bacon suppressed his first Studies after Velazquez. This is characteristic of his temperament and method of working, as a tireless seeker after perfection whose suffered periodic attacks of crippling self-doubt, forever taking colossal risks and promptly despairing at their outcome.
It was for this reason that he referred to so many of his paintings as studies, as if a definitive solution to the problem lay beyond the limit of his abilities. In bacon's view Velazquez was definitive: conceiving their works in necessarily fragmentary terms, modern painters were fated to remain aware of a discrepancy that could never be resolved. However, there were two sides to the coin:
on the one hand, the realisation that the masters were unsurpassable forced the modern artist to acknowledge and accept his own limitations, but on the other, it represented a continual challenge, spurring him to renew his efforts in the pursuit of an impossible goal. And what goal could be more impossible than that of emulating Velazquez's portrait on Innocent X?
In the summer of 1950 Bacon began to paint a series of variations on Velazquez's portrait for his second exhibition at the Hanover Gallery in London. He had often worked this way in the past, making pictures with a specific exhibition in mind; the knowledge that the opening date was fast approaching had a particularly galvanising effect on him. The Pope series was originally supposed to comprise three pictures, but only two of the
planned works were executed before Bacon abandoned the project in a fit of dissatisfaction. When the exhibition opened in September 1950 not one of the Popes was on display. Many years later Bacon described his study of Velazquez as a 'failure' and categorically condemned its results. Referring to Portrait of Innocent X, he said he had tried 'very unsuccessfully to do certain records' of the painting, but these had been 'distorted...
I regret them, because I think they're very silly.' When his involvement with the Velazquez portrait came to an end, the picture seemed more remote and perfect than ever. Thus, Bacons obsession with Velazquez heft a bitter after taste, a lingering sense of futility. This throws a curious light on his interest in Velazquez. Bacon evidently regarded his study of the portrait of Innocent X as a struggle. Nut what or who was he struggling with,
and what was the purpose of the conflict?
Most, if not all, of Bacon's Pope paintings seethe with aggression, with anger and hatred. Some interpreters have also detected irony in them, although most find this view impossible to share. A further aspect, apparent to any viewer, is the sense of commitment and passion. Bacon is an artist for whom painting invariably means conflict and struggle: he is fighting all the time, even though he keeps a cool head and retains full control over what is happening on the canvas.
This partly stems from the fact that he is pitting his own technique against the abilities of one of the great classical masters. Yet the real target of Bacon's struggle is not Velazquez's canonical standing, but the philosophy on which the Spaniard's art is based. Bacon rejects Velazquez's entire vision of the Pope. He opposes the principals of hierarchical order and spiritual authority that the Pope embodies, and regards the static world-view underpinning the portrait of Innocent X as fundamentally false.
Though he acknowledged its consummate mastery of the means of expression , Bacon saw Velazquez's art as deeply flawed, insofar as the world it depicted was obsolete and decayed. Bacon raises the Pope to an impossible height in order to knock him down all the more dramatically from his pedestal. His aim is to subvert the traditional conception of the world handed down via the Church and the artists acting on its behalf. But the Pope resists the maltreatment of his image and tries to halt the impending collapse of the established world order.
The pope is Bacon's negative hero. He screams and grimaces, clutching at the arms of his throne or raising his fist and threatening to strike back at his opponent. Thus the pictures in Bacon's Pope series are painted in the face of palpable resistance.
Bacon needed this resistance, especially at the beginning of his artistic career. To him, it was a precondition of working, for it established the necessity of his art. He painted against the crucifixion, against
the triptych form,
against
Velazquez. And through his very opposition to these models, he made use of their possibilities. He needed canonical themes, canonical forms and masters, as targets, in order to focus his own energies. It was only by addressing challenges that he could mobilise the resources at his disposal. He had to find
his own images, his own vision, his own style, by confronting his ideals with those of others and allowing them to prove their worth in open competition. He could find himself only through questioning. His own ideas could take shape only by departing from the time-worn traditions of painting and establishing specific differences of principal. This is why he needed the background of tradition in which the art of Velazquez was a central element.
In opposing Velazquez's picture, Bacon was not only attacking a masterpiece by an individual artist; he was launching a general assault on five centuries of European easel painting. But in order to do this, his study of Velazquez's portrait on Innocent X had to engage with the traditions that it sought to criticise and accept their basic framework of assumptions. The result was that Bacon wrote himself into the history of classical art precisely by rebelling against it.
See also
Study for a website for Francis Bacon - THE PAPAL PORTRAITS OF 1953
The Popes of Francis Bacon
| |
Head VI, 1949
Study after Velazquez, 1950
Study after Velazquez II, 1950
Pope I, 1951
Pope II, 1951
Study for the Head of a Screaming Pope, 1952
Study after Velazquez's Portrait of Pope Innocent X, 1953
Figure with Meat, 1954
Study for Imaginary Portrait of Pope Pius XII, 1955
Portrait of a Cardinal, 1955
Study for Portrait I, 1953
Study for Portrait II, 1953
Study for Portrait III, 1953
Study for Portrait VI, 1953
Study for Portrait V, 1953
Study for Portrait VI, 1953
Study for Portrait VII, 1953
Study for Portrait VIII, 1953
Study from Innocent X, 1962
Pope and Chimpanzee, 1962
Portrait of Man with Glasses III, 1963
Study from Innocent X, 1965
'Study of Red Pope 1962' Second Version, 1971
| | | |
Core |